Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
1 2 3
A 93 year old person with dementia should be at a facility with memory care. Us "normal" people are not equipped to deal with all of the issues that come with someone who has this disease, no matter how much we wish we could. That is the reality of the situation.
You don't need to justify to anyone why you do what you do. The answer is no. Plain and simple. They don't need to like it, they don't need to understand it (but I bet your siblings do understand) they just need to accept it.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

You can't live your life trying to make everyone else happy.  Tell them you are going to be the best daughter you can be by assisting your mother in finding the best care available.  Running yourself into the ground and giving up your life doesn't make you a better daughter and if your siblings need you to do that then they don't have your best interests at heart.  Help your mom find a great place half way between you and your siblings so that everyone can visit mom.

Don't let them bully you into doing something you don't want to do.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Great question great responses. With Covid now I’m struggling with this same issue, but these viruses are adding more fear.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

To quote my sister in law (who loved my mom dearly) "well, I always thought mom would come live with us, but with this dementia thing and the delusions, no, not happening".

Dementia is a one way street. It does not get better. But it IS better to get someone with early dementia into a facility while they still have some skills that will allow them to adjust.

You are perfectly justified in saying that moving in with you is not the best care plan for mom. She needs professionals, not tired and retired children, caring for her.
Helpful Answer (14)
Report

Wish I could follow my own advice sometimes... but... Just say, "I just can't. Sorry" and don't say why except "I just can't". If you give them a reason the'll come up as to why you can. She may outlive you. Keep that in mine when saying it as many times as you need to. There are plenty of nice assisted living places out there. Keep us posted. Stay strong.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

I’m 61 & my mother is 93. I’m in good shape & health ...have no husband or children but have home a mother with dementia who sometimes gets violent. She’s incontinent & immobile. She gets transferred with lift machine. I discharged her 3 years ago from SNF she was in for 10 months. She declined much & needs medications for agitation. I’m exhausted. DON’T TAKE HER HOME!!!!!!! You will regret it.
HUGS 🤗!!!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

DO NOT DO IT! You will regret it. You don't have to explain anything really - just say it's not possible. Your mother sounds like she needs to be in a nursing home. Your dementia will only get worse - along with the rest of her problems. If she wants to stay in her home - then she will need home health care. I'm getting to that point now - my mother is in my house and is 93. She does o.k. except for the fact that she tries to STILL tell me what to do - how to spend my money when I have worked for 40 years! I'm just waiting to retire - SSN at 62. She keeps telling me that I wouldn't have to still work if I would just quit spending money. Trust me - I buy clothes on the clearance rack, color my own hair, and hardly EVER take a vacation. Only a night away for a year. I'm so tired of this life but with the pandemic am really stuck at the moment. I plan to tell her she needs to figure something out because I CANNOT take care of her. I have joint issues - cannot bend down and pick someone up or help her shower when it gets to that. God Bless - but find other avenues. I too feel like I deserve to have a life - she has lived with me off/on for over 20 years. I'm just tired as she can be a very manipulative, negative, narcissistic person. She has also driven a wedge between other family members. So no one really comes around to see/visit her. Tired of this!!!!
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

As a 66 y.o. who just retired and brought Mom who is 95 to live with me 2 years ago, say NO. It is going ok for me at the current time, but my youngest, the 38 y.o. lives between with me and her longtime boyfriend who lives a mile away. They are over here a lot which helps tremendously. ( My brother passed away a few years ago, so I am the only child. )

But different things are a constant struggle, and I have no life outside of home. Be strong, say NO, don't let it get started. Find a good place for her to live in assisted living and then you and your siblings can visit.

It is a constant struggle for instance having her use her walker, bending over to pick things up. She is SO unsteady. She constantly leaves her walker in a different room and "forgets" it vs. purposely leaves it. Her vision and hearing are not good. Memory so-so. She is a very young 95 and very healthy; I see her living to and past 100. I love my mom very much, but if she has one bad fall and breaks anything, she will wind up in a nursing home for sure.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I think you need to answer your question by asking yourself what if your children were saying “no” about you,
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Kimber166 May 2020
I have told my son to say "no" to me - to having me in his home, having to diaper me, having to deal with dementia, having a strain on his marriage and family life of someone who needs mean that the family can never go on vacation, to being stressed at work and home trying to stretch to cover everyone and their needs.

I have asked him to say "yes" to helping me find somewhere that will give me the care i need 7x24 by trained professionals.

I have asked him to say "yes" to visiting me, being my son, being involved in my life.

You don't have to be hands on "no" to still be an involved and loving child.
(13)
Report
See 1 more reply
Ricky, that's a perfectly fair point - provided that you first of all imagine yourself to be 93 years old and very much attached to your own ways.

You would also have to imagine expecting your children to make the necessary sacrifices, which I for one hope will remain unthinkable.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
disgustedtoo May 2020
I've already told my kids not to worry about me. If I end up following my mother down that yellow brick road, find a nice place for me, ensure I'm getting cared for and live your life. Don't feel you have to do any more than that if you have reservations. Caring for someone who is older and needs assistance is one thing. My parents took one grandmother in and took turns with siblings, but she was EASY to care for and did NOT have dementia. They were also probably in their 50s and she was 70 something. My mother was already 90 when dementia kicked in, living on her own and ADAMANT she wasn't going to move anywhere, esp AL (although that had been in her own plans before dementia kicked in!)

I also see Kimber166 posted something similar. It's kind of a silly question to ask oneself. Knowing what I know now about dementia and what I deal with at my age without the 24/7 hands-on is tough and I WON'T expect my kids to do any more than I did. The decision has to be based on what you feel you can do yourself, not what some other person thinks (or demands) you should do.
(1)
Report
You care for her as much as possible already. What do your siblings do for your mother? Where do they live?

What are her finances? Can she afford an assisted living place? Can she afford hiring her own in-home caregivers? Why hasn't that been considered? I hope the attitude isn't that "Mama will never go into a home."

Whatever you do, do NOT take her temporarily "to see how it goes." Say no and mean it from the beginning.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

You are seeking approval, not advice, for a decision you are struggling with. Most of us have been in the same or a similar situation. Just remember, the decision you make will be one you will live with for the rest of your life. If you feel guilty now it will be compounded after she is gone. We all come into this world depending on help and we leave the same way. And you will someday find yourself in the same situation. What goes around comes around.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
disgustedtoo May 2020
To be honest, I don't see OP "struggling" with a decision about whether to take her mother in or not, but rather OP is asking how to say NO nicely to the others, who likely expect OP to do everything and get nothing (except flak) for it. Regardless of their own shortcomings, why should OP give up everything and let them skate? That's where I would be now if I had taken mom in, against better judgement. Bros, after our first "tour" finally got the big picture and cost - they both said "for that kind of money they'd take her in"... Surrre they will. Never went beyond that one statement, and now neither visits or has any dealings with her. I do the visiting (until the lock down), manage everything for her and advocate for her. No help, just criticism from them.

As for the guilt, it is being spoon fed to OP by siblings and maybe mom - PLUS you (and others like you.) The guilt is not about wanting to have a life.

Also, the statement you made "...the decision you make will be one you will live with for the rest of your life." is NOT true, it is only another layer of guilt from one of the 'guilt trip travel agents' we are hearing about. If OP had a change of heart, or felt capable at some later point to take mom in, the decision CAN be undone. Most decisions can be changed. The only decision that has been final in my own experience is euthanasia. Can't bring back any of my cats once that decision has been made and acted on. ANYTHING else CAN be changed, but I don't see any reason why OP *must* take her mother in and ruin her life and health just to gratify the guilt-trippers, whether they be family, friends or some know-it-all on a forum.
(5)
Report
I have to agree with the comments suggesting that you just say no. Although a lot of people will disagree with your decision, and disagree with this post, we personally had to make this decision a long time ago and it was the right thing to do. The people who condemned us have moved on. My mother-in-law was fine mentally, but physically was giving out. We were under pressure to take her in by her friends and church. But, these people knew only the woman she wanted them to see, and not the woman we knew her to be. All of the children knew what would happen to their lives and their marriages if one of us decided to take her in. I knew this woman for over 40 years and I could go into detail about what problems she caused through our married life, but I'll let my husband's 3 other siblings multiple failed marriages speak for that. She was intrusive and manipulative, a thing my husband recognized around our third year of marriage, and he was the only one who was able to distance himself from her manipulations and handle her in a way that allowed us to remain part of the "family" but immune to her attacks. But, we also recognized that living with these attacks 24/7 would wear on us, and we know better than to invite this into our home when there are workable alternatives. Every family situation is different, and you have to decide for yourself. Making sure your mother is safe and cared for, in my opinion, is your responsibility, be it at her home with caregivers, in a nursing home, etc. Being pressured by outsiders who could never know your actual situation will always be an issue, but go with your gut and don't let other people guilt you into doing something you are going to regret. Yes, their comments and snubs will hurt and be hard to take, but you don't owe anybody any explanation for your decisions, you have to do what is right for you. We made this decision 8 years ago, and still get asked why we didn't you let her move in with us, but we just say "we made the decision that was right for Mom and the family." Good luck! Stay strong, and know there are those of us who completely understand and have made the same hard decisions and lived through it.
Helpful Answer (13)
Report
jacobsonbob May 2020
Good points. I wonder how many of the "guilt-trip travel agents" have spent years in hands-on caring for a parent or other elderly person. The condition of an elderly person having physical issues and dementia will get "worse, worser, and worserer" over time, perhaps driving the caretaker crazy or dead before reaching "worser-est"--a play-on-words that sums up what most of the hands-on caretakers posting here have described.

As I posted once before, I knew a widow who was taking care of a still-older person in her home (I believe she was earning some extra money this way). I mentioned that the older woman always seemed so pleasant when I visited. The caretaking woman said "Oh, you haven't seen what she's like when no one is visiting!" Some people spend their entire lives being "two-faced", and it certainly doesn't improve when they get older, especially if dementia creeps into the picture! (And some who WEREN'T normally two-faced become that way due to dementia which STILL causes problems even if the caretaker tries to overlook it.)

I hope the OP takes the warnings, posted by so many here from first-hand experience, seriously!
(7)
Report
See 2 more replies
Do not let her live with you if you can avoid it. I wish someone had told me how difficult it would be before my Mom came to live with me 7 1/2 years ago. She is 91 years old now with dementia and it keeps getting more difficult.She has never appreciated the scarifice my family has made to have her live with us. Keep your Mom where she is if you can.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Please, just say "No, I am not able to" or "It is not possible for me to care for mom at this time". You do not need to explain why; it is your business. If she comes into your home she will never go to MC or a NH, and you may live the rest of your years being her staff, and/or die before she does. Do not feel guilty! You have your own life to live! Best wishes.
Helpful Answer (13)
Report

Could you and your siblings help your Mom find an ALF that has higher levels of care as well? I do not recommended having your Mom live with you, and I strongly disagree with comments others have made about “guilt”. I would never want to guilt my kids into taking me in! I do not ever want to be a burden to them!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

You have a meeting with the siblings to discuss the best options for your mom. Could she moved to assisted living nearer to you and them? Just kids visiting is a plus when done on a regular basis. See who can offer what in the way of taking care of her if she was in a reasonable distance to all of you. If neither of them can offer any kind of help, then find a place close to you and tell them you cannot do the 24/7 job alone.

If finances allow, could 24/7 care be paid for if she did live in your home? That could be an option and you would be free to carry on with things you planned for retirement life. Financial situation is going to determine what kind of paid help you could get or type of facility she could live in. You might start the conversation there.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Bootsielou May 2020
Just say No. Do not take her into your home. I know how awful this becomes with your parent not trusting help who comes daily to help. She was so nice to the caretaker until the caretaker went home then there was a total personality change. Your mom took care of you as a child and I know the guilty feeling of not being there 24/7 but you will regret bringing her into your home unless you are totally prepared for a different lifestyle and becoming the caretaker.
(0)
Report
Simple: "NO." The more you try to explain and support your answer the less convincing it is. There will never be enough reasons for your sibs to take it on themselves as long as they think they might be able to bully you into it. If your reasons are enough for you, they are enough.

I am currently doing very little for my mother as my sisters and I decided that only one should go to Mom's during this crisis. Until I was completely free to do my gardening and run my life without those commitments, I had no idea how much stress a day or two with Mom each week added to my life. All of my sisters agree with me that we are glad we did not let Mom come and live with any of us. We are all in our late 60's/70's and it is more than enough stress to spend a day or two per week at Mom's house. At this point, I wish I had never been willing to "care" for my mother at all. I love visiting her, talking to her on the phone. I simply do not want the responsibility of her inabilities and her constantly deteriorating mind, body, and house. I wish that I had taken a few years between work and my own old age to do some travel, have some fun.

Be assured, if your Mom needs 24/7 care it is not possible for you or anyone else to do it alone. If she needs that kind of care she needs residential care, not an enslaved daughter. Say "No" and mean it.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Set mom up in a nice senior apt or assisted living facility. It was a lifesaver for me.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I almost thought that I wrote this post because I am in a very similar situation, so I wish you much luck!! My mother IS with me now and wants to go home, but with her mild dementia and this virus, it isnt possible yet. Her psych evaluations are on hold. I contacted an assisted living specialist and we talked about sending her to a facility because I am burnt out and my siblings are useless. I will have an uphill battle as they either want her at her home or with me as I dont "work." I do have a life, however, and this situation is making me angry and resentful. Mom is getting more and more impatient with the quarantine and sleeps and sulks a lot. I hope you can say "no" and not feel guilty and get hassled by your siblings and anyone else. I'm finding it harder and harder to control my emotions with her and I feel a confrontation coming on with family. I do not have POA, so I hope I can convince my siblings to see my perspective. Good luck to you! I feel your anguish. Apparently, there are a lot of people in our predicament.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

One of my friends had to relocate in 2019 from CA to NV. She had done distance POA for her 96-year-old mother for one year until she died at her CA facility.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Just say no. Hold your ground. If your heart and mind are unwilling to care for your mother full time, then it would be a mistake for you to do so because of pressure. Why can't your siblings care for her? How come you were nominated? You live an hour away. Moving your mother in with you would necessiitate a change in physicians, hospitals, hairdressers,churches, friends,family- all things familiar and comforting to her. So not only would you be dealing with a possible cognitive decline; you would be dealing with a definite adjustment. In my area, there is a program through the Y called s3nior shared housing. A senior is paired with a younger senior who needs housing. In return, the roommate helps with household chores. Maybe that would work for you. Or if your mother has funds, a caregiver could be hired. Or you all can chip in and hire a caregiver. Guilt is never a good motivator.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Seems like it time for a family discussions about your mom and her future needs. It is a family issue, not just your issue, to deal with. With your siblings and their spouses, discuss what types of care you mom needs now and types of care that may be required in the future. Each person should decide what he or she is able and willing to complete - without pressure. Tasks that do not have a "taker" may need to be farmed out to a paid person - independent caretaker or home health car aide through an agency or a residential facility. Every person should help in researching options and finding out your mom's resources through insurance, social security, medicare...

Has mom been diagnosed with dementia? If not, a doctor visit is the next step.

Does mom have have will, Powers of Attorney (medical and financial), and living will or Do Not Resuscitate documents? If not, then a trip to a family lawyer is required.

It is initially a lot of work, but eventually it becomes more manageable.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Couldn't she stay with you and get caregivers?
I mean mom's sacrifice so much themselves raising kids.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
NYDaughterInLaw May 2020
Moms choose to have children.
(6)
Report
See 2 more replies
This is an easy one. Say NO.

What's hard is the guilt you may feel about saying no. You need to recognize you are placing this pressure on yourself. If mom has assets or income to support it, it's time for assisted living. If she doesn't have the finances, contact your county's office on services for the aging. See what day programs are available for social engagement (once the covid nightmare is manageable). Are there waivers available for some daily home care? There are likely a lot of programs you don't know about. Explore them.

But, first decide that your mom is NOT going to move in with you. Your siblings 'can't' take her in and neither can you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Momsgoto,
It seems to me that having Mom move in with you doesn't truly solve everything.
You say she does "ok" right now, however, you are seeing her mental decline.
You work fulltime. And sibs are unable to care for her.
Is Mom able to afford an in home caregiver?
Eventually Mom will reach the point that she is unable to safely be alone.
Most of us on this site understand how painful these decisions are.
You have to make the decision that you can live with!
You want Mom to be safe and well cared for, but you don't want to be resentful either.
Hang in there!
God bless!!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I would not give too many reasons for your answer. No, that won't work for me. No, I can't. No, Mom, we'll have to think of something else.

Whenever I offer a reason for saying no, I end up having to justify the decision over and over. I have learned that No is a complete sentence. Say No.

My husband's family has a habit of speaking indirectly. I have found it helpful to restate what they are saying "Are you saying I should be doing more to help with Mom?" "Are you saying we should visit more often?" I find it very helpful to make sure that I am interpreting the indirect comments properly and not receiving the wrong messages. It also brings the issue front and center so I can clearly communicate with them. I don't understand talking in hints. So much miscommunication can go on.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report
Holdingon70 May 2020
Absolutely love that! Continuing to explains keeps you stuck. No IS a complete sentence. When you know in your heart you are giving all you can with no reciprocal assistance, when you know sometimes you just have to save yourself....then it's no with no apologies.
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
You've had a lot of good advice and need to go with your own gut instincts about taking on this herculean task. I chose not to. My brothers considered it when they found out what it costs, but never went beyond stating it once...

The best you can hope for is that they will work with you in finding the best solution for your mother's care. Just hinting or saying you should do it, what makes it better for you than them? Just because you might be a bit younger and almost done with full time employment? Not a good reason.

Do also work on getting everything needed in order - POAs, will, trust for assets, etc and research all the options. Every facility and every EC attorney will have different costs and offerings, so you'll have to research a lot while making plans! As noted in some of my responses to others, even the non-hands-on care takes a lot of time and effort, but you can remain your mother's daughter AND advocate for her without taking on the 24/7 care!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Do keep in mind that your mother will not likely stay in her current state of dementia and needs. This could and likely will get worse. You need to plan for this and make the best decision now to include this in your decision making re: placement. It would be more disruptive to her and you to have to move her acutely.
I share as have been there. Adjustment now is better for your mother and this does not mean not being involved.
My best to you and your mother.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

obviously your siblings have reasons they cannot do it but you have reasons too.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

1 2 3
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter