Follow
Share

My mom sadly passed away yesterday at 11 AM from chronic respiratory failure among other things. I was her caregiver for over 10 years and enjoyed every minute of it, but in the last 3 to 4 years, she was so weak she could hardly cross and cross her own legs totally chair bed bound.



Right when the doctors were talking about hospice care end of life and how she wanted to not fight anymore.



One thing I said out of anger is I will never forgive you for giving up. We later talked about it and I said I did not mean it etc. but I think it was still in the back of her mind.



And while she was actively dying. That by the way was the most incredibly painful difficult thing I’ve ever done in my life. I watched her take her last few breaths.



I was just wishing it would hurry up and happen. Because it was so hard and painful for me to sit and watch it. What kind of selfish monster am I?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Thank you all for your kind and supporting words, it all made me cry like a big baby. And very much helped!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
AlvaDeer Apr 27, 2024
Thank you for letting us know we could help at all. Please do keep us updated as you take this journey.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
You wanted her to go on and pass BECAUSE YOU LOVED HER SO MUCH! You loved her enough to want her to be at peace. The most selfless thing you could do for her.

I love my parents, and when it’s their time to go, I pray for it to be peaceful and not drawn out. I felt the same way when I sat by my grandmother as she was breathing her last. She was ready to go and I wanted her to go and receive peace. It’s the passing we all wish for those we love.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

So sorry for your loss. 💖🌹💖
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

If you are a monster, then most of us who weigh in on this site are also monsters.

Being relieved when a LO's suffering is over is something we just DON'T talk about--but when my Mom died (about 18 months ago) and my MIL died (2 months ago)...well, with mom, it was such a sweet blessing that she passed with zero drama. My MIL was a drama queen and died the way she lived--angry and hateful to so many people. I have never been to a viewing/funeral that had less 'grief' in it.

When time came to close the casket, DH's sister practically climbed inside it with her mother. Kind of embarrassing...then my DH turned around and looked at his mom and turned back. OB didn't even LOOK at her, not once, in that casket. He nodded to the funeral director and said "We're good". The closed and locked the casket w/o OB even looking inside. (Viewings are kind of barbaric, to me.)

These 3 incredibly different reactions to the exact same situation and spoke VOLUMES about the relationships she did/didn't have with her children.

We had been actively praying for her to pass for over a year. Her life was miserable and as she slowly, slowly died, she managed to suck all the joy out of all 3 of her kids' lives. My DH is nowhere near where he needs to be, emotionally--and he didn't do ANYTHING wrong.

Stop the negative self talk. 10 years is a very long time to put your life on hold for someone else. My DH knows that if he gets too much for me to care for, he is going to go into care. Same with me. I will not do that to my family.

Grieving is normal, but life does go on. Please let it go and move forward. Get some help from a counselor. You can't care for someone for that length of time and call yourself a monster for saying one thing out of fatigue & exhaustion.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Where does this negative thought process come from? Negative self-talk breeds more negativity, not a good way to handle your grief.

You are not a monster, you did the best you could, she was dying, that is that.

If you cannot get this negative self-talk out of your mental loop, please consider therapy.

Sorry about mom, however, we are all born to die, it is called attrition.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Not a monster. Monsters don't take care of someone with love for ten years. I'm sure there were a lot of emotions swirling inside you at the time of your mother's passing, which bubbled up as anger—like immense sadness at her death or fear of what comes next for you when she's gone. Don't beat yourself up for it. She knew you loved her. I'm a mom, and I have a 6yr old who often tells me he hates me, and I know that when he says that it's out of hurt or fear or any other emotion besides actual hate, and I'm sure your mom recognized it in your words as well.

My mom died after passing out, and hitting her head (she was dying before that, but that's what ended the wait). It took her a week to die after the fall. It was awful to watch, and I told her she could go on the first day. I didn't want to watch her die, and she deserved better than to die slowly in that way after all she had done for us. So I don't think you're a monster. Watching someone you love die is horrible. You obviously loved her so much, and I have no doubt she would want you to let the guilt go.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

A "selfish monster" would never have cared for a loved one for over 10 years.
Nor would a "selfish monster" want someone they love to linger on any longer in such a weak condition where they were no longer living just because they were still breathing.
You did your very best and your mom knew that. She was very fortunate to have you by her side all this time and especially when she took her last breath.
Take comfort in the fact that your mom is now at peace and that she doesn't have to suffer any longer. That should be a great relief for you.
I hope and pray that you will now take care of yourself and allow yourself whatever time it takes to mourn the mom you loved.
And know that your mom would not want you feeling bad about anything, but instead would want you moving forward now in a healthy and whole manner.
Best wishes in doing just that.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I am so sorry for your loss. My deepest condolences to you and your family.

Give yourself a break though. You did all the caregiving for years and you deserve praise and respect for that alone. You're not the only person in the world who's had an off moment because the pressure of caregiving got to them. God knows I've had plenty of them and so has everyone else that's ever had to take this journey. There's not a person on earth who has never said something in the heat of anger, or out of desperation, or out of sheer exhaustion that they didn't regret after they've calmed down, received help, or had a rest.

Having an off moment under near impossible circumstances and conditions doesn't make you a monster.

It makes you a human being.

You talked it over with your mother and told her you didn't mean it. She knew you didn't mean it.
Actions speak louder than words, my friend. Your ten years of service and care, and a lifetime of love you had for your mother are actions far drown out a few words spoken in haste and exhaustion.

Do yourself a favor and don't keep rehashing this in your mind over and over because you'll drive yourself crazy.

It's time for you to have a rest and to show yourself some kindness.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Beethoven13 Apr 26, 2024
Yes, yes, Yes, to all of Burnt's reply. Stop rehashing and show yourself the kindness and peace you deserve. A big hug. You will be okay. Take it day to day and Know, you did a Great job taking care of mom. Its time to take care of you for a while.
(2)
Report
None of know what to expect in the dying Process . My brother was quite Ill the last year of his Life . I Really never Knew what to expect - Often times I sat by His bed and watched him sleep . There are still times I wish I had gone to visit him when he asked me " to stay in a hotel nearby " or " Can you come today on Sunday ? " But I did take care of him at home for 6 Months . I Knew I would be the One to deal with Hospice . Yes It was Incredibly Painful to watch and I had some of the best Doctors But No Family support . We had a good time the Last year of his Life and I try and remember eating Pizza with him at the Hospital cafeteria or sitting Outside On a Indian summer day Knowing this would be our Last time and he said " This weather Is Like the Bahamas Karen I could live in this weather forever . " So my advice is to think about the Joy and Laughter you shared with your Mother instead of the pain .
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

My mother passed away on March 3 from chronic respiratory failure. She was bed bound at the end, after 3-4 years of serious illness. I was her primary caregiver, and I felt much the same way. I don't think of myself as a monster. I prefer to think I did the best I could to help her while she was alive, and held her hand while she took her last breaths. I did the best I could, and I'm sure you did, too.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

You were mom's caregiver for 10 years and enjoyed every minute of it, yet question "what kind of monster" you are for wanting to rush the death process for a DYING woman? Who in her right mind would want to EXTEND the death process????? That's a better question to ask, don't you think?

Expecting this level of perfection from yourself is unhealthy and unnatural. You did more for your mom than 99.9% of anyone else on earth has done for theirs. Acknowledge that instead of beating yourself up for some imagined transgression. Remember you're human.

My condolences on the loss of your dear mom.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
AlvaDeer Apr 26, 2024
Your "Expecting this level of perfection from yourself is unhealthy and unnatural" is likely the most profound statement in this thread, Lea.

It is very disturbing, given the level of caring love here, that this OP would describe herself as a "monster". It is worrying.
(2)
Report
I think we all have done this when we know a LO is in the dying process. Its a stressful time. For me Dad died in his sleep and Mom was pronounced 20 min after I had left the NH. Yes, I prayed that God take her soon for days. Not so much for me but for her.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Monster? Nah. Just a human being with limitations. Not god. Not a Saint. Just a human being under extreme pressure and grief.
You said what you said out of love.
You and she spoke about it afterward, and she understood that.
It is very unlikely, as busy a time as the dying have with dying, that she thought about what you said.
I spent my life as an RN. The dying remove themselves from us before they leave. They are busy on their last journey--the one we don't know about until we take it. There is an expression as old as medieval times that says "He (she) turned his (her) face to the wall". That meant that it was now too hard for them to take their journey and still pay attention to those of us still living.

I am so sorry for your loss.
You are now experiencing grief and loss, and given the amount of care you invested your mom became your very life. It is a sort of a death for YOU as well as for her.
You fully know all you did. You don't require our reminding you of it, or reassuring you.
Guilt isn't appropriate here. You didn't cause your mom's illness and death and you couldn't have fixed it. The better G-word is GRIEF and you are trying to avoid that with blame.
That's a normal reaction. Those in profound grief will choose instead to be angry at someone: anyone will do; doctor, nurse, hospital, aid, and EVEN OURSELVES.
Grief is that dark woods you will have to enter. It is fearsome and sad.
Write your mother notes in a journal about your feelings, your memories, the sad time, the happy ones, the bickers, the blessings. Collage it with cutouts and make it beautiful.

Your feelings will lose these sharp edges with the sands of time.
If they don't you will see someone to help, whether pastor, faith community, psychologist, social worker in private practice, doctor for some medication to help bridge you over these waters, new friends, support groups (facebook has great support groups for grieving).
You will make your way.
Your going on with life does your mother honor. That's what she would want for you.
My heart goes out to you. Allow yourself to mourn in your own way and be easy on yourself and your feelings.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Beethoven13 Apr 26, 2024
Very thoughtful and beautiful reply. This kind of support and knowledge is why I, (maybe we) are here. Its kind of profound the depth of your understanding. Thank you.
(1)
Report
I watched every minute of my dad’s last hours and minutes. It was unlike any other experience I’ve ever had, and among the many emotions and thoughts, one was for it to hurry up and end. It’s unnatural to watch and feel helpless in any situation, so our human defenses go to a place of wanting it to end. No one wants to feel someone we love is suffering. Please stop beating yourself up over this. Just as your mother was born exactly when she was meant to be, she also left this life exactly when she was meant to, and nothing you did or didn’t do was ever going to change this. Acceptance will be a gift to you. I’m sorry for your loss and wish you healing and peace
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

People behave and say things differently than they usually do when under extreme stress. You are human.

Please forgive yourself. I’m certain your mother did, I’m also certain she gave you grace for why you said it.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

BigSky, I'm so sorry for your loss and your misplaced feelings of guilt. If you're a monster, so am I.

I think it's totally expected to want the dying process over with; my sister in law and I, sitting with my mom as she struggled to breathe, said to me "why is this taking so long?". She looked up and said "Pop, time to come get Mom!"

We started playing my parents' favorite music. It eased the fear for us and I hope my mom.

You are not a monster. Please be kind to yourself.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
ElizabethAR37 Apr 26, 2024
Big Sky: Absolutely NOT a monster! However, situations like this are why I sincerely hope that when my time comes, I will be on hospice or palliative care and medicated so that I am not struggling to breathe or suffering pain. That's a worst-case scenario for me. I do NOT want that for my family or myself!
(1)
Report
I'm so sorry for the loss of your Mom. You are NOT a selfish monster.

It is a grueling process for an infant to be born, and it can be a grueling process to leave this life. You simply wanted the process to be less painful for her. That is a mature unselfish love, and not all love is flowers and rainbows.

I hope I can leave this life swiftly and with as little pain as possible and would be happy for my friends and family to pray and hope for a swift passing.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Anxietynacy Apr 26, 2024
Dog wood, I don't know how to send her the thread on , wishing your loved one would die. Lots of good stuff there for her there if you know or anyone knows how to send it to her.

I'm still learning how to navigate this forum
(0)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter